Suzanne Mettler and Robert C. LiebermanNov 23, 2020
The Recurring Crises of American Democracy
St. Martins Press 2020
The United States experienced race-baiting, polarization, executive overreach, and inequality before the presidency of Donald Trump. Does that political history demonstrate resilience – or vulnerability? Suzanne Mettler (John L. Senior Professor of American Institutions in the Government department, Cornell University) and Robert C. Lieberman (Krieger-Eisenhower Professor of Political Science, Johns Hopkins University) use insights gleaned from comparative politics (particularly the study of liberal democratic and authoritarian regimes) and American politics to interrogate five periods in American political history to argue that there are four central threats to American liberal democracy: political polarization, racism and nativism (issues of who belongs), economic inequality, and excessive executive power. The United States has faced these political threats (even combinations of them) in the past. But those periods of political conflict have had serious, long-term consequences for the robustness of American political institutions and practices. At the beginning of the 21st century, Mettler and Lieberman observe all four: a unique and serious state of affairs.
Four Threats: The Recurring Crises of American Democracy (St. Martin's Press, 2020) highlights five political moments that span three centuries. “Polarization Wreaks Havoc in the 1790s” unpacks the emergence of factions and proto-parties emerging over the Alien and Sedition Acts – and highlights how the rhetoric of John Adams (targeting of immigrants, the press, and demonizing his political opponents) parallels that of Donald Trump. “Democratic Disintegration in the 1850s” charts the breakup of the Union and Civil War. “Backsliding in the 1890s” interrogates debates over voting rights, identity, and citizenship – and the remarkable violence that enforced white supremacy as states stripped Black Americans of the voting rights that helped protect their civil and political rights. The national government failed to effectively uphold those rights, leaving most Black Americans without effective voting power for over 60 years. In “Executive Aggrandizement in the 1930s,” Mettler and Lieberman demonstrate how Franklin D. Roosevelt’s forceful use of executive power to thwart fascism in Europe and respond to broad public needs in the United States opened the door for the use of power for other purposes. In “The Weaponized Presidency in the 1970s,” they show how Richard Nixon deployed that power to punish political enemies but also how each branch played their constitutional roles to force a president from power.
Designed for students and all readers interested in American history and politics – trying to make sense of the 2016 election and contemporary American politics, the book provides clear and concise definitions of any political science terms or theories. Lieberman has written on race and politics (e.g., Shaping Race Policy: The United States in Comparative Perspective and Shifting the Color Line: Race and the American Welfare State) and Mettler has focused on gender, citizenship, and inequality (e.g., The Government-Citizen Disconnect (NBPS with Heath Brown), Degrees of Inequality: How the Politics of Higher Education Sabotaged the American Dream (NBPS with Marshall Poe), The Submerged State: How Invisible Government Policies Undermine American Democracy, Soldiers to Citizens: The GI Bill and the Making of the Greatest Generation, and Dividing Citizens: Gender and Federalism in New Deal Public Policies). Four Threats combines their expertise in American with insights from comparative politics defining of democratic regimes.
Four Threats not only makes sense of the four threats using political science and history but also aims to provide voters with tools to assess the health of American democracy today. Is it a full or flawed democracy? Endangered or merely damaged? Four Threats aims to sensitize voters to a critical moment that requires them to consider candidates and policy in light of whether American democracy will be strengthened or weakened by their choices.
Susan Liebell is associate professor of political science at Saint Joseph’s University in Philadelphia. She is the author of Democracy, Intelligent Design, and Evolution: Science for Citizenship (Routledge, 2013) and, most recently, “Retreat from the Rule of Law: Locke and the Perils of Stand Your Ground” in the Journal of Politics (July 2020). Email her comments at firstname.lastname@example.org or tweet to @SusanLiebell.