Arguing History

Arguing History

episodes

Scholarly discussions of controversial historical topics.

The Idea of "Central Europe" from Naumann to Kundera

November 24, 2023

The Idea of "Central Europe" from Naumann to Kundera

Martyn Rady and Alexander Watson
Hosted by Charles Coutinho

Central Europe has long been infamous as a region beset by war, a place where empires clashed and world wars began. In The Middle Kingdoms: A New Hist…

The Gaza War in Military-Historical Perspective

October 16, 2023

The Gaza War in Military-Historical Perspective

Jeremy Black
Hosted by Charles Coutinho
Listen:

In this interview military historian Jeremy Black examines ongoing Israeli-Hamas conflict in Israel and the Gaza Strip in historical perspective. Blac…

Socialist Cultures and Politics of Secularism and Atheism

June 13, 2023

Socialist Cultures and Politics of Secularism and Atheism

Todd Weir and Victoria Smolkin
Hosted by Stephen Bittner
Listen:

Two new books on secularism and atheism in German and Soviet socialist cultures are reshaping scholarly understandings of the relationship between soc…

New Histories of Violence in and around the Second World War

June 10, 2023

New Histories of Violence in and around the Second World War

Max Bergholz and Nicole Eaton
Hosted by Stephen Bittner
Listen:

Why does state-led and intercommunal violence occur? How do past episodes of mass violence reverberate in the present? How do victims and perpetrators…

Empires after World War II: The Cases of the USSR and France

May 20, 2023

Empires after World War II: The Cases of the USSR and France

Rachel Applebaum and Emily Marker
Hosted by Stephen Bittner

Where lay the fissures of Soviet power in Eastern Europe during the Cold War? Why did France fail in its postwar efforts to make its African colonies …

Soviet Hippies and German “Other ‘68ers”: A Conversation about Youth Non-Conformity and Protest

February 28, 2023

Soviet Hippies and German “Other ‘68ers”

Juliane Fürst and Anna von der Goltz
Hosted by Stephen Bittner

On first glance, Soviet hippies would seem to have little in common with right-wing student protestors in West Germany in 1968. Yet as Juliane Fürst a…

Rethinking the End of the Russian and Habsburg Empires

February 21, 2023

Rethinking the End of the Russian and Habsburg Empires

Joshua Sanborn and Dominique Kirchner Reill
Hosted by Stephen Bittner

Historians often think of World War I and the period surrounding it as the acme of nationalism in European politics. In two very different books, Josh…

The Russo-Ukrainian War from a Military Point of View

January 3, 2023

The Russo-Ukrainian War from a Military Point of View

Jeremy Black
Hosted by Charles Coutinho

On February 24 2022, Vladimir Putin shocked the world by invading Ukraine. In this short interview, veteran military historian Jeremy Black looks at t…

On the Life and Legacy of Queen Elizabeth II

October 6, 2022

On the Life and Legacy of Queen Elizabeth II

Jeremy Black
Hosted by Charles Coutinho

Queen Elizabeth II died on September 8, 2022. She reigned for 70 years, longer than any other British sovereign. In this interview, Charles Coutinho d…

How Should We Remember Winston Churchill?

September 21, 2022

How Should We Remember Winston Churchill?

Jeremy Black
Hosted by Charles Coutinho

How should we remember the complicated figure of Winston Churchill? Was he (in the words of Prime Minister Harold Macmillan) "The greatest Englishman …

Ukrainian Nationalism in Historical Context

June 21, 2022

Ukrainian Nationalism in Historical Context

John-Paul Himka, David R. Stone, and Alexander Watson
Hosted by Charles Coutinho

In the midst of the ongoing war between the Russian Federation and Ukraine, it is vital that the lay-educated public understand the historical origins…

Are We Entering a "Neo-Medieval" Era?: A Conversation with Greg Lewicki

June 3, 2022

Are We Entering a "Neo-Medieval" Era?

Greg Lewicki

Our world is being marked by a transition of epochs towards a more “Neo-Medieval” era. What is even meant by “Neo-Medieval”? Greg Lewicki argues that …

Putin's War on Ukraine in Historical Perspective

May 24, 2022

Putin's War on Ukraine in Historical Perspective

Jeremy Black, Thomas Otte, David R. Stone, and Alex Watson
Hosted by Charles Coutinho

With the war in Ukraine showing no signs of stopping anytime soon, it was thought a worthwhile idea to have an informed discussion with four expert hi…

Philip Dwyer and Mark Micale, "The Darker Angels of Our Nature: Refuting the Pinker Theory of History & Violence" (Bloomsbury, 2021)

October 19, 2021

The Darker Angels of Our Nature

Philip Dwyer and Mark Micale
Hosted by Galina Limorenko

In The Better Angels of Our Nature Harvard psychologist Steven Pinker argued that modern history has witnessed a dramatic decline in human violence of…

Why did the US Fail in Afghanistan?

September 30, 2021

Why did the US Fail in Afghanistan?

Jeremy Black
Hosted by Charles Coutinho

With its ultimate debacle in August 2021, a discussion of the twenty-year military involvement of America and the West in Afghanistan is most timely. …

Jeremy Black, "Clio's Battles: Historiography in Practice" (Indiana UP, 2015)

March 5, 2021

Clio's Battles

Jeremy Black
Hosted by Charles Coutinho

To write history is to consider how to explicate the past, to weigh the myriad possible approaches to the past, and to come to terms with how the past…

The Cold War as History

July 21, 2020

The Cold War as History

Hosted by Charles Coutinho

The Cold War, the on again and off again confrontation between the West and the Soviet Union is one of the most famous historical episodes of the shor…

Why Did the Allies Win World War One?

June 11, 2020

Why Did the Allies Win World War One?

Jeremy Black
Hosted by Charles Coutinho

The Great War was perhaps the greatest single upheaval of the 20th century. While World War II saw more lives lost, in terms of the shock to European/…

Why Did the Allies Win World War II?

April 27, 2020

Why Did the Allies Win World War II?

Hosted by Charles Coutinho

Why did the Allies win World War II? In the this podcast of Arguing History, Professor of History Emeritus at Exeter University, Jeremy Black and D…

The Origins of World War One

March 12, 2020

The Origins of World War One

Hosted by Charles Coutinho

Who or what originated and/or caused the Great War from breaking out in July 1914? Was it Serbia with its expansionist and aggressive designs on Austr…